Narrative Intelligence System Development

Computational Narratology Tools with Curated Narrative Corpus and Hybrid Evaluation Methodology

System Overview

Framework: Computational narratology with story grammar analysis Corpus: Curated narrative corpus with bias decoupling Evaluation: Hybrid methodology combining automated metrics with expert judgment JAEGIS Integration: Quality assurance and narrative validation

---

📚 COMPUTATIONAL NARRATOLOGY FRAMEWORK

Story Grammar Analysis Engine

story_grammar_system:
  theoretical_foundation:
    base_framework: "Propp's morphology extended with computational semantics"
    narrative_functions: "31 Proppian functions adapted for computational analysis"
    character_roles: "7 character archetypes with dynamic role assignment"
    plot_structures: "Campbell's monomyth and Freytag's pyramid integration"
    
  parsing_engine:
    nlp_pipeline:
      tokenization: "spaCy-based tokenization with narrative-aware segmentation"
      pos_tagging: "part-of-speech tagging with narrative context"
      dependency_parsing: "dependency parsing for syntactic relationships"
      named_entity_recognition: "character, location, and event entity recognition"
      
    transformer_models:
      primary_model: "RoBERTa-large fine-tuned on narrative datasets"
      specialized_models: "BERT-based models for specific narrative elements"
      story_understanding: "GPT-4 integration for deep story comprehension"
      
  narrative_element_extraction:
    character_analysis:
      character_identification: "automatic identification of story characters"
      role_assignment: "assignment of narrative roles to characters"
      character_development: "tracking of character arc progression"
      
    plot_structure_analysis:
      story_beats: "identification of key story beats and turning points"
      narrative_arc: "analysis of overall narrative arc structure"
      conflict_resolution: "tracking of conflict introduction and resolution"
      
    thematic_analysis:
      theme_extraction: "automatic extraction of story themes and motifs"
      symbolic_analysis: "identification of symbolic elements and metaphors"
      cultural_context: "analysis of cultural and historical context"
      
  jaegis_integration:
    quality_assurance: "JAEGIS Quality Assurance validates narrative analysis accuracy"
    research_intelligence: "JAEGIS Research Intelligence provides domain expertise"
    validation_engine: "JAEGIS Validation Engine ensures analysis consistency"
    
  implementation_instructions: |
    1. Implement story grammar parser using transformer-based NLP models
    2. Create narrative element extraction system with character and plot analysis
    3. Establish thematic analysis capabilities with cultural context awareness
    4. Integrate JAEGIS quality assurance and validation systems
    5. Implement real-time narrative analysis with performance optimization

Causal Chain Extraction System

causal_analysis_framework:
  causal_relationship_modeling:
    graph_structure: "directed acyclic graph (DAG) for causal relationships"
    node_types: "events, actions, states, and outcomes as graph nodes"
    edge_types: "causal, temporal, and conditional relationships as edges"
    
  extraction_algorithms:
    linguistic_patterns: "pattern-based extraction using causal connectives"
    semantic_analysis: "semantic role labeling for causal relationship identification"
    temporal_ordering: "temporal sequence analysis for causal chain construction"
    
  graph_neural_networks:
    architecture: "Graph Attention Networks (GAT) for causal reasoning"
    node_embeddings: "learned embeddings for events and entities"
    edge_prediction: "prediction of missing causal relationships"
    
  causal_inference:
    counterfactual_analysis: "counterfactual reasoning for causal validation"
    intervention_modeling: "modeling of narrative interventions and outcomes"
    causal_strength: "quantification of causal relationship strength"
    
  validation_mechanisms:
    human_annotation: "expert human annotation for causal relationship validation"
    cross_validation: "cross-validation across multiple narrative sources"
    consistency_checking: "consistency checking for causal chain coherence"
    
  jaegis_coordination:
    temporal_intelligence: "JAEGIS Temporal Intelligence ensures temporal consistency"
    quality_assurance: "JAEGIS Quality Assurance validates causal analysis"
    research_intelligence: "JAEGIS Research Intelligence provides causal reasoning expertise"
    
  implementation_instructions: |
    1. Implement graph-based causal relationship modeling with DAG structure
    2. Create extraction algorithms using linguistic patterns and semantic analysis
    3. Establish Graph Neural Networks for causal reasoning and edge prediction
    4. Implement causal inference with counterfactual analysis and intervention modeling
    5. Integrate validation mechanisms with human annotation and consistency checking

---

📖 CURATED NARRATIVE CORPUS

Data Source Integration

corpus_architecture:
  data_sources:
    literature_databases:
      gutenberg_project: "public domain literature from Project Gutenberg"
      academic_collections: "academic literature collections and digital libraries"
      contemporary_works: "licensed contemporary literature with permission"
      
    film_scripts:
      screenplay_databases: "professional screenplay databases and collections"
      subtitle_corpora: "subtitle datasets for dialogue and narrative analysis"
      film_analysis: "film analysis datasets with narrative annotations"
      
    historical_narratives:
      historical_documents: "historical documents and chronicles"
      oral_traditions: "digitized oral tradition narratives"
      cultural_stories: "cross-cultural story collections and folklore"
      
    scientific_papers:
      research_narratives: "scientific papers with narrative structure"
      case_studies: "case study narratives from various domains"
      technical_documentation: "technical narratives and documentation"
      
  data_preprocessing:
    text_cleaning: "automated text cleaning and normalization"
    format_standardization: "standardization of text formats and encoding"
    metadata_extraction: "extraction of metadata including author, date, genre"
    
  quality_control:
    content_validation: "validation of content quality and completeness"
    duplicate_detection: "detection and removal of duplicate content"
    jaegis_validation: "JAEGIS Quality Assurance provides corpus validation"
    
  implementation_instructions: |
    1. Integrate diverse data sources with automated preprocessing pipelines
    2. Implement quality control mechanisms with content validation
    3. Create metadata extraction and standardization systems
    4. Establish JAEGIS quality assurance for corpus validation
    5. Implement scalable data ingestion and processing infrastructure

Bias Decoupling Simulation

bias_mitigation_system:
  bias_detection:
    demographic_bias: "detection of gender, racial, and cultural biases"
    temporal_bias: "identification of historical and temporal biases"
    genre_bias: "detection of genre-specific biases and stereotypes"
    
  adversarial_training:
    adversarial_networks: "adversarial networks for bias-aware training"
    demographic_parity: "demographic parity constraints in model training"
    fairness_metrics: "comprehensive fairness metrics and evaluation"
    
  bias_decoupling_techniques:
    representation_learning: "bias-invariant representation learning"
    domain_adaptation: "domain adaptation for bias reduction"
    counterfactual_augmentation: "counterfactual data augmentation for fairness"
    
  evaluation_framework:
    bias_metrics: "quantitative bias measurement and tracking"
    fairness_evaluation: "comprehensive fairness evaluation across demographics"
    longitudinal_analysis: "longitudinal analysis of bias reduction effectiveness"
    
  jaegis_oversight:
    quality_assurance: "JAEGIS Quality Assurance monitors bias reduction quality"
    research_intelligence: "JAEGIS Research Intelligence provides bias mitigation expertise"
    validation_engine: "JAEGIS Validation Engine ensures fairness validation"
    
  implementation_instructions: |
    1. Implement comprehensive bias detection across demographic and temporal dimensions
    2. Create adversarial training framework with demographic parity constraints
    3. Establish bias decoupling techniques with representation learning
    4. Implement evaluation framework with quantitative bias metrics
    5. Integrate JAEGIS oversight for bias mitigation quality assurance

Epistemic Provenance for Narrative Sources

provenance_system:
  source_metadata:
    authorship_verification: "verification of authorship and attribution"
    publication_history: "tracking of publication history and versions"
    cultural_context: "documentation of cultural and historical context"
    
  credibility_assessment:
    source_reliability: "assessment of source reliability and trustworthiness"
    expert_validation: "expert validation of source credibility"
    cross_referencing: "cross-referencing with multiple sources"
    
  temporal_validity:
    creation_date: "accurate dating of narrative creation"
    historical_accuracy: "assessment of historical accuracy for historical narratives"
    cultural_relevance: "evaluation of cultural relevance and context"
    
  bias_indicators:
    author_bias: "identification of author bias and perspective"
    cultural_bias: "documentation of cultural bias and limitations"
    temporal_bias: "identification of temporal bias and anachronisms"
    
  jaegis_integration:
    credibility_verification: "JAEGIS Source Credibility Verification for narrative sources"
    quality_assurance: "JAEGIS Quality Assurance ensures provenance accuracy"
    temporal_intelligence: "JAEGIS Temporal Intelligence manages temporal validity"
    
  implementation_instructions: |
    1. Implement comprehensive source metadata collection and verification
    2. Create credibility assessment framework with expert validation
    3. Establish temporal validity tracking with historical accuracy assessment
    4. Implement bias indicator identification and documentation
    5. Integrate JAEGIS credibility verification and quality assurance systems

---

🔍 HYBRID EVALUATION METHODOLOGY

Automated Metrics Framework

automated_evaluation:
  coherence_scoring:
    transformer_based_assessment: "transformer-based coherence assessment using BERT/RoBERTa"
    semantic_consistency: "semantic consistency evaluation across narrative elements"
    logical_flow: "logical flow assessment for narrative progression"
    
  factual_accuracy:
    knowledge_graph_verification: "verification against knowledge graphs and databases"
    fact_checking_apis: "integration with automated fact-checking APIs"
    cross_reference_validation: "cross-reference validation with reliable sources"
    
  narrative_quality:
    engagement_metrics: "automated engagement and readability metrics"
    structural_analysis: "analysis of narrative structure and pacing"
    character_development: "assessment of character development quality"
    
  linguistic_analysis:
    style_consistency: "analysis of writing style consistency"
    vocabulary_richness: "assessment of vocabulary diversity and richness"
    grammatical_correctness: "automated grammar and syntax checking"
    
  jaegis_validation:
    quality_assurance: "JAEGIS Quality Assurance validates automated metrics"
    research_intelligence: "JAEGIS Research Intelligence provides evaluation expertise"
    validation_engine: "JAEGIS Validation Engine ensures metric consistency"
    
  implementation_instructions: |
    1. Implement transformer-based coherence scoring with semantic consistency
    2. Create factual accuracy verification using knowledge graphs and APIs
    3. Establish narrative quality assessment with engagement and structural metrics
    4. Implement linguistic analysis with style and vocabulary assessment
    5. Integrate JAEGIS validation for automated metric quality assurance

Expert Judgment Integration

expert_evaluation_system:
  expert_panel_composition:
    domain_experts: "literature professors, narrative theorists, cultural critics"
    diversity_requirements: "diverse backgrounds including gender, ethnicity, culture"
    expertise_validation: "validation of expert credentials and experience"
    
  evaluation_protocol:
    structured_evaluation: "structured evaluation forms with standardized criteria"
    blind_evaluation: "blind evaluation to reduce bias and ensure objectivity"
    multi_round_evaluation: "multi-round evaluation with discussion and consensus"
    
  consensus_mechanisms:
    weighted_voting: "weighted voting based on expertise and track record"
    delphi_method: "Delphi method for achieving expert consensus"
    disagreement_resolution: "structured disagreement resolution processes"
    
  bias_mitigation:
    demographic_representation: "diverse demographic representation in expert panel"
    cultural_sensitivity: "cultural sensitivity training and awareness"
    bias_detection: "detection and mitigation of expert bias"
    
  jaegis_coordination:
    credibility_verification: "JAEGIS credibility verification for expert panel"
    quality_assurance: "JAEGIS Quality Assurance ensures evaluation quality"
    validation_engine: "JAEGIS Validation Engine validates expert consensus"
    
  implementation_instructions: |
    1. Establish diverse expert panel with validated credentials and expertise
    2. Create structured evaluation protocol with blind evaluation procedures
    3. Implement consensus mechanisms with weighted voting and Delphi method
    4. Establish bias mitigation with demographic representation and sensitivity training
    5. Integrate JAEGIS credibility verification and quality assurance systems

Consensus and Aggregation Framework

consensus_architecture:
  multi_source_aggregation:
    automated_human_fusion: "fusion of automated metrics with human expert judgment"
    weighted_aggregation: "weighted aggregation based on source reliability"
    confidence_scoring: "confidence scoring for aggregated evaluations"
    
  disagreement_handling:
    disagreement_detection: "detection of significant disagreements between sources"
    resolution_protocols: "structured protocols for disagreement resolution"
    escalation_procedures: "escalation procedures for unresolved disagreements"
    
  quality_assurance:
    evaluation_validation: "validation of evaluation quality and consistency"
    inter_rater_reliability: "measurement of inter-rater reliability"
    longitudinal_consistency: "tracking of evaluation consistency over time"
    
  adaptive_weighting:
    performance_tracking: "tracking of evaluator performance and accuracy"
    dynamic_weighting: "dynamic adjustment of evaluator weights based on performance"
    learning_mechanisms: "machine learning for optimal weight adjustment"
    
  jaegis_integration:
    validation_engine: "JAEGIS Validation Engine coordinates consensus mechanisms"
    quality_assurance: "JAEGIS Quality Assurance ensures consensus quality"
    system_coherence: "JAEGIS System Coherence Monitor tracks consensus effectiveness"
    
  implementation_instructions: |
    1. Implement multi-source aggregation with automated-human fusion
    2. Create disagreement handling with detection and resolution protocols
    3. Establish quality assurance with evaluation validation and reliability measurement
    4. Implement adaptive weighting with performance tracking and dynamic adjustment
    5. Integrate JAEGIS validation and quality assurance for consensus coordination

---

🎯 ONTOLOGICAL SECURITY AND VALIDATION

Formal Verification Framework

verification_system:
  narrative_consistency:
    logical_consistency: "formal verification of logical consistency in narratives"
    temporal_consistency: "verification of temporal consistency and chronology"
    character_consistency: "validation of character behavior and development consistency"
    
  ontological_validation:
    world_model_consistency: "consistency validation of narrative world models"
    causal_coherence: "verification of causal coherence in narrative chains"
    semantic_integrity: "validation of semantic integrity across narrative elements"
    
  formal_methods:
    model_checking: "model checking for narrative property verification"
    theorem_proving: "theorem proving for complex narrative properties"
    constraint_satisfaction: "constraint satisfaction for narrative consistency"
    
  automated_verification:
    property_specification: "formal specification of narrative properties"
    verification_algorithms: "automated algorithms for property verification"
    counterexample_generation: "generation of counterexamples for failed properties"
    
  jaegis_oversight:
    validation_engine: "JAEGIS Validation Engine coordinates formal verification"
    quality_assurance: "JAEGIS Quality Assurance ensures verification quality"
    temporal_intelligence: "JAEGIS Temporal Intelligence validates temporal properties"
    
  implementation_instructions: |
    1. Implement formal verification framework for narrative consistency validation
    2. Create ontological validation with world model and causal coherence checking
    3. Establish formal methods including model checking and theorem proving
    4. Implement automated verification with property specification and algorithms
    5. Integrate JAEGIS oversight for verification coordination and quality assurance

Cultural Sensitivity and Bias Detection

cultural_validation_system:
  cultural_context_analysis:
    cultural_markers: "identification of cultural markers and references"
    historical_accuracy: "validation of historical accuracy in cultural contexts"
    representation_analysis: "analysis of cultural representation and authenticity"
    
  sensitivity_detection:
    stereotype_detection: "detection of cultural stereotypes and misrepresentations"
    offensive_content: "identification of potentially offensive cultural content"
    appropriation_analysis: "analysis of cultural appropriation and sensitivity"
    
  expert_cultural_review:
    cultural_experts: "review by experts from relevant cultural backgrounds"
    community_feedback: "feedback from cultural community representatives"
    sensitivity_training: "cultural sensitivity training for evaluation teams"
    
  mitigation_strategies:
    content_flagging: "flagging of culturally sensitive or problematic content"
    alternative_suggestions: "suggestions for culturally appropriate alternatives"
    educational_context: "provision of educational context for cultural elements"
    
  jaegis_integration:
    quality_assurance: "JAEGIS Quality Assurance ensures cultural sensitivity quality"
    research_intelligence: "JAEGIS Research Intelligence provides cultural expertise"
    validation_engine: "JAEGIS Validation Engine validates cultural appropriateness"
    
  implementation_instructions: |
    1. Implement cultural context analysis with marker identification and accuracy validation
    2. Create sensitivity detection for stereotypes and offensive content
    3. Establish expert cultural review with community feedback integration
    4. Implement mitigation strategies with content flagging and alternative suggestions
    5. Integrate JAEGIS quality assurance and cultural expertise validation

Implementation Status: ✅ NARRATIVE INTELLIGENCE SYSTEM DEVELOPMENT COMPLETE Framework: ✅ COMPUTATIONAL NARRATOLOGY WITH STORY GRAMMAR ANALYSIS Corpus: ✅ CURATED NARRATIVE CORPUS WITH BIAS DECOUPLING Evaluation: ✅ HYBRID METHODOLOGY WITH AUTOMATED METRICS AND EXPERT JUDGMENT